Jaguar Cichlid or Senegal Bichir / Questions

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Which of the 2 do you prefer?


  • Total voters
    33
id go jaguar cichlid since i like those more and actually a 100 gallon would be fine for a single jag..ultimate chice is yours though..
 
yeah im thinking im gonna give the jag a try as long as when i go the ones they have are healthy, if the bichirs look healthier it'll be an even tougher decision i appreciate all the input tho :)
 
Good luck dude!

Wish I had a tank that could hold a jag.
 
I'd choose a Jag. If the Jag you get is anything like my fish, you wont be disappointed. I truely think it's one of the smartest fish I've ever had.
 
i think the poll says it all :P jag it is (in a few weeks anyways once my tank has been cycled, by then i may have changed my choice again uhg lol)
 
These people saying to get a Jag are giving advice without even knowing the facts. What are the tanks dimensions? Is it a 100g long? I can guarantee most of these guys haven't grown a Jag out to full size and don't know just how big they can get. If it's a 4' tank, it won't be fair to a full grown male Jag, you need at least a 6' x 18" tank in the long run. If it's a 4' tank there's still plenty of awesome cichlids to choose from that will fit the bill....you don't have to go with the bichirs lol.

@ alexpie, senegals don't sit at the bottom of tank all day long, they're very active.
 
Adult size for senegal bichirs is 8-12", senegals over 12" are extremely rare. I chose the bichir for that tank size. 180 gallon minimum for a jag, imo (or at least a 5x2x2 150).
 
Senegals are very active, mine were always always swimming around mid-lower levels of the tank. They would also go to the surface when they would see me approach the tank and wait for food. I highly recommend them.
 
What are the dimensions of the 100g? There are a lot of cichlids you can keep with the bichirs. If you are only getting 2 senegal bichirs,you could easily add a large SA/CA cichlid. With the right foot print,you could even keep a jag with them. I would not just keep 2 sens in a 100. Lots of options of fish you could keep with them.
 
I agree, and depending on the tank's footprint, you could keep various cichlids with the senegals. Their scales are like armour. Actually I used to have a couple and my cichlids totally ignored them.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com