Hi Josh. Are you planning on upgrading in the next year or will this tank be their permanant home? You might have said somewhere else in the thread and I missed it. You shouldn't get the JD unless you do plan on an upgrade shortly. Just stay with smaller sized cichlids like convicts, firemouth, salvini, neets, sajica, cutteri, HRP, rainbow, australius, balzani, etc. Of course not all together, you would have to research what you like and what's compatible. There's also over 50 species of apistogramma and all sorts of dwarf cichlids. Also dwarf crenicichlia (pike cichlids) make great pets. Remember, just because a fish fits in a tank doesn't mean he's comfortable. GL and have fun with it.