Odd Question for MFK: Catfish for a 23 Gallon?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Bottomfeeder;2744876; said:
whiptail as in adonis? as in
Black-Adonis-Pleco.jpg
?

Wow!!!! That's big!!!

Get a jaguar catfish. They get 6" and they're really pretty.
 
Bottomfeeder;2744876; said:
whiptail as in adonis? as in
Black-Adonis-Pleco.jpg
?
I didn't know the Acanthicus adonis is also called whiptail pleco.:grinno:

I am referring to L010a, Sturisoma panamense, Rineloricaria parva and Farlowella acus, a few of those I can mention.;)
 
AU_Arowana-RG;2743223; said:
Yes, I live in Cebu.

So, what kinds of fancy plecos would work?

Also, would the Glass Catfish be too big and eat the Corys and Upside-downs?
Glass catfish grow to 6 inches max only and are community fish. You haven't answered my question for tank dimensions yet.

See these sales threads. Please double check all sizes before you buy and be sure you can accommodate the pleco permanently.
http://mypalhs.com/forums/showthread.php?t=82508

http://mypalhs.com/forums/showthread.php?t=81796

Sturisoma panamense

Spanamense01.jpg



Red Lizard Pleco
L 10a (Hemiloricaria sp. ‘Red’)

RedLizard01.jpg




dragonfish;2743226; said:
Never had much luck with glass cats in a community tank. Very shy and non-competitive, will starve to death if they have to fight for food.
:iagree: Keep the glass catfish with corydoras and small plecos.
 
basslover34;2747652; said:
Actually Jags will get about 50% bigger than that and are not suited for a 29G tank, personally I'd be looking for pictus or something like a wood cat or I have a Leiocassis poecilopterus in a small tank and he does very well.


Are you sure they get that big? Most info on the net says 7-10 inch. Ive questioned a few actual people who've owned them and all have said they never got over 7 inch.

Im not trying to insult you or anything, Im just asking a curious question. I also agree, a jag cat is not suitable for a 29 gal.
 
Pyramid_Party;2747673; said:
Are you sure they get that big? Most info on the net says 7-10 inch. Ive questioned a few actual people who've owned them and all have said they never got over 7 inch.

Im not trying to insult you or anything, Im just asking a curious question. I also agree, a jag cat is not suitable for a 29 gal.

Most sites I see say 8-10". Even if a jag doesn't achieve this size, any fish significantly smaller than it will be a snack.
 
To the OP: SA bumblebees are great. I keep several in a 37 gallon with 2 bristlenoses and a L-201 and I see them all the time. Otherwise, I would consider a small group of woodcats.
 
ahodge84;2747767; said:
Most sites I see say 8-10". Even if a jag doesn't achieve this size, any fish significantly smaller than it will be a snack.


My point is, I would rather hear that a fish reach that size by an actual aquarist who owned one of that size. Alot of times sites on the web are inaccurate or copy and paste from one another. Im just kinda curious thats all. I would like to hear more from people who have owned them. The few I have talked to said no larger than 7 inch. So I will believe that until theres proof of one larger.


But back on topic, bottom line this catfish isnt suitable for this tank.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com