Oscar

[dmed]

What do you guys think about an Oscar and a Dempsey in there? Too much?

I think too much, due to territorial-issues more than actual fish size.

 

[gomezladdams]

Sounds like a good setup,decent prices.
My oscar shares a 75 with a firemouth and a royal pleco

 

[dmed]

I think too much, due to territorial-issues more than actual fish size.

Also, see what other people think... but that's my opinion.

 

[haynchinook334]

JD will go good in there.
1 oscar
1 m JD
1 f JD

 

[rmorse]

JD will go good in there.
1 oscar
1 m JD
1 f JD

Are you serious? A male and female paired JD will DESTROY an Oscar, esp. in a 75.

 

[haynchinook334]

Are you serious? A male and female paired JD will DESTROY an Oscar, esp. in a 75.

i have 1 oscar and 1 male and female JD in a 55gal....i see no prob.

 

[dmed]

Are you serious? A male and female paired JD will DESTROY an Oscar, esp. in a 75.

I was worried about one or the other!

 

[dmed]

i have 1 oscar and 1 male and female JD in a 55gal....i see no prob.

What size and for how long?

 

[haynchinook334]

JD's are 6 to 8" and the Oscar is 6 inches. had them in the tank for two month.

 

[HPIZZLE]

thats insane
i had an 11 inch oscar and an 8 inch JD in a 110 and the oscar got
D-E-S-T-R-O-Y-E-D!!!!!!!!