Oscar

[rmorse]

JD's are 6 to 8" and the Oscar is 6 inches. had them in the tank for two month.

Just out of curiosity, what are you going to do when the Oscar is bigger then the 12 inches that your tank is? Same thing with the Jack Dempsey's, but the Oscar will reach it first.

I mean, do you honestly expect to keep the 3 of them in a 55 for life?

 

[xFLEAxx]

okay man well ill keep the oscar in there and see how it goes. Ill keep you guys posted

 

[rmorse]

Sounds good Flea. Good luck!

 

[haynchinook334]

Just out of curiosity, what are you going to do when the Oscar is bigger then the 12 inches that your tank is? Same thing with the Jack Dempsey's, but the Oscar will reach it first.

I mean, do you honestly expect to keep the 3 of them in a 55 for life?

come on guy...i have other tanks, not just one.

 

[BushFishRox]

I would recommend just staying with 1 Oscar and then a school of 6 Silver Dollars

 

[xFLEAxx]

okay cool thanks guys. Im going to pick up the tank now but I have to pick up the lights and stand from other people. Right now im getting the tank, heaters, and filters. Pictures will be up tonight. Thanks for the advice guys.

 

[haynchinook334]

hope all works out bro.

 

[xFLEAxx]

Thanks bro I appreciate it

 

[artemis1]

Haynchinook, your stocking is the exception, not the rule. I doubt it will work for many others.

I would recommend just staying with 1 Oscar and then a school of 6 Silver Dollars

 

[rmorse]

come on guy...i have other tanks, not just one.

Well, "come on guy", why would you tell someone who has only one tank to stock their tank with that then? I mean, seriously...You just straight up told this guy that he can do an oscar with 2 JD's, saying you are doing it now. You were implying that he can do it for life, which is not true. What gives man?


OP: DO NOT PUT JACK DEMPSEY'S IN THE TANK.