Oscars for the 125

[HybridFinatic]

Glad I don't care what you think. Here is the nasty cruel tank.

View attachment 1367188

Why create more conflict?

 

[LBDave]

Why create more conflict?

No conflict here. Maybe somebody else....

 

[DawnMichele]

The recommendation of 4 Oscars plus other fish in a tank that size is not a good recommendation. 4 keyhole cichlids would be a good recommendation for at tank the size of the OP's.
Am I the only one here that sees this?
Why do people have to cram these big, active, intelligent fish into these size tanks?
Even if you keep the fish fin perfect and disease free, is this really good practice?
So many modest sized fish In the hobby to choose from, let's put 4, 12+inch fish in a four foot tank. Sorry, but seems unfair and unnecessary to me. I don't think a solo oscar can be happy in a four foot tank.
Each to their own though.
I also believe silver dollars should be in much bigger groups to feel comfortable and in a tank of minimum, 6+feet.

My Oscar Big Boy LOVES his 125 by himself!!!!

 

[RD.]

There will only be 2 oscars in my 6 foot tank

Just 2 Oscars? I'm not quite following your end game plan here? SD's, geos, etc, and two O's, or just two O's?

 

[FINWIN]

Just 2 Oscars? I'm not quite following your end game plan here? SD's, geos, etc, and two O's, or just two O's?

Sounds like all of them together, or maybe 3 Os if he gets rid of one tiger if I'm understanding this

 

[-603FiShHoBbIeSt-]

Just 2 Oscars? I'm not quite following your end game plan here? SD's, geos, etc, and two O's, or just two O's?

There will be 6 silver dollars, 2 red tapajos, and 2 red oscars

 

[-603FiShHoBbIeSt-]

Sounds like all of them together, or maybe 3 Os if he gets rid of one tiger if I'm understanding this

I will have 2 reds

 

[RD.]

Ok, your tank, your call, but if it was me I would stick with a max of just the two O's. As it is you are going to have to do large frequent water changes (as in min of twice a week) & frequent filter cleaning. Good luck.

 

[-603FiShHoBbIeSt-]

Ok, your tank, your call, but if it was me I would stick with a max of just the two O's. As it is you are going to have to do large frequent water changes (as in min of twice a week) & frequent filter cleaning. Good luck.

I will post updates as the oscars grow and when I add them to the 125, these fish will not be neglected in anyway. I understand everyone’s opinions here and I get it, everyone has there own way of keeping fish and what they think is best or right from wrong, but I’m going to try the plan I have in mind for this tank and if it doesn’t work out then I’ll go from there. Thank you

 

[FINWIN]

I will post updates as the oscars grow and when I add them to the 125, these fish will not be neglected in anyway. I understand everyone’s opinions here and I get it, everyone has there own way of keeping fish and what they think is best or right from wrong, but I’m going to try the plan I have in mind for this tank and if it doesn’t work out then I’ll go from there. Thank you

I don't necessarily think you're wrong its just for sure those cute lil' Os will grow geometrically and put out a "bio load multipler". Think of it as mass equals poop squared!