Required tank size

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
the flower horn and mayan might work but the jags ussally go crazy once they put on some size but check out palmer aquatics on youtube he had a 125g setup with jags red devils and I believe he has even had a couple FH in their too
These guys look so peaceful, I'm stumped.
 
keep the 75 ... get a 180 .. then figure out which goes where .. you will probably need 2 tanks....
Yup, good advise. The FH should remain in the 75, Jag gets a larger tank. The Mayan, being the most docile..shall be place in either, with lots of hiding place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lp85253
Even in a 8ft 300g, a mellow jag will pin other fish in the other 3-4 feet of a tank. That’s a mellow jag, a more aggressive one will do worse, from shredding fins to killing.
Mine is a female. Might still work. Thx
 
All great advices from experienced cichlid keepers over here. Thanks a lot, guys!
 
Well.. Shall stick to plan. Can give away the Mayan if things don't work out.
These are definitely not cichlids for newbies. ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kelly_Aquatics
Yup, good advise. The FH should remain in the 75, Jag gets a larger tank. The Mayan, being the most docile..shall be place in either, with lots of hiding place.
that's a decent idea.. another thought i just had.. put the jag in the 75 by itself .. it may well never outgrow it .. i know others will think i'm nuts, but i have a 12" black belt living happily in a 75 with a bp and 2 striped raphy's (due to a tank blow out)...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Al KW Tan
These guys look so peaceful, I'm stumped.
I see quite a bit of chasing and some shredded tails even just in that short video of the tank, severum looks pretty torn up. That guy may also have gone through many fish which didn't make it before finding a mix that worked out OK, and with these big cichlids it can all change over night.
It is certainly possible to keep "non advisable" mixes, or keep more densely stocked tanks than most would recommend. Years ago it was the norm, I remember having a 90 gallon which was overstocked and a 125 full of big bruisers. The thing is, I lost some fish that I shouldn't have because of it. Biggest Lyonsi I have ever seen straight from jeff rapps, got absolutely shredded one night after everything being fine for a while. Just for one example, I'm sure I lost more over the years. Which is why I am much more conservative when giving advice for these big fish nowadays.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com