Either way, the same concept still applies...BrtnBoy449;4514787; said:no. i indicated that it was suitable. i was only saying that it was extreme to say that "a 55 gallon tank for a rd would be like living in a closet" and was implying that a 75 gallon isn't much different than a 55 gallon and is only wider, so saying that having a rd in a 55 gallon would be like living in a closet would be like saying a rd in a 75 gallon is like living in a walk in closet, sure you'll be able to turn around easier, but its still a closet.