Shipment surprise

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Some more pics are coming soon. And either way him/her was a freebie and my daughter really likes its color so i believe she is going to put it in her planted tank for now.
 
creepyoldguy;4949655; said:
It's not so much color as it is the size and pattern of scales that differentiate the cyano from the carpintes. Either way, thats a nice little free fish and hopefully the OP will have some pics up sooner!

Okay then. You can't see either of those things in the pictures, so how can you try to encourage an arguement over it? :screwy: lol

If you are that well versed on these two species, then maybe you should tell the OP what the defining characteristics are?
 
dbD1nonly;4949666; said:
Some more pics are coming soon. And either way him/her was a freebie and my daughter really likes its color so i believe she is going to put it in her planted tank for now.

That's the spirit!
 
Piscine;4949681; said:
Okay then. You can't see either of those things in the pictures, so how can you try to encourage an arguement over it? :screwy: lol

If you are that well versed on these two species, then maybe you should tell the OP what the defining characteristics are?


OK...... First of all, I think the majority of people here have decided it is either h. carpintes or h. cyano. That we CAN tell from the picture. THe picture is still too blurry, in my opinion, to determine which species it is, especially since these species are very similar. There is not argument over it except the one you are trying to start.

I am not, nor have I claimed to be so well "versed" on these species, but unlike yourself, I do know both species are similar in color and that is not the determining factor to seperate the two.

I can tell you that if you look aroud and different pictures of both adult species, it is fairly easy to tell them apart once you know what a cyano looks like and once you know what a carpintes looks like. As juvies, they are harder to I.D., especially with all the hybrids that occur.
 
I'm gonna say carpintis because of the way the "jeweled" spots are shaped.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com