Should the Ebola infected Americans be allowed in US?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Status
Not open for further replies.
A little bit more from the 'as a trained professional' side... It's not a matter of coming 'home' in terms of seeing family. It's a matter of coming 'home' where the facilities are up to providing the support you need to attempt survival against the disease, without fear of your supplies getting looted or your caretakers murdered, or your room set on fire (with you in it) by paranoid mobs. They have an awareness of the risks, yes, but the fact of the matter is that they were motivated to help in those areas because the conditions are BAD in the first place, and are not going to magically improve simply because it happens to be a doctor that got sick. The field facilities are understaffed and undersupplied. Many of the local assistants are just simply not showing up, leaving the foreign volunteers to take on more work in stifling heat, which affects their judgment. There is nothing to keep those same local assistants from just not showing up at the hospitals either once patients arrive there. There have been some rumors that the gear is being reused in the field -- but even if that is the case, there is enough going around that there is a GOOD chance that they may have been exposed while even not working directly with patients (and thus not wearing the protective equipment). He had already turned down serum to give to the other sick volunteer. I certainly would be thinking 'my chances are better in Europe or in the States, and the risk of me getting /others/ sick is LOWER than if I stayed here'. Also, as a trained professional, he has a great advantage over the average patient -- the role of PATIENT COMPLIANCE and PATIENT AWARENESS when it comes to interacting with his caretakers. He is in a coherent enough state that he can help prevent exposure to his attending healthcare workers, and minimize his own spread.

Hello; You have again raised the issue of the quality of care available for the infected doctor. To my understanding that is not what we began discussing in this thread. That he will get better care in the Atlanta facility is a given in my opinion. The issue is that in having him here in the states some uneeded level of risk has been imposed on the rest of us. He now has a somewhat better chance for survival.

The bad events you bring up in Africa are a part of the deal. I admire someone willing to put his/her life at risk to help others. That was a noble decision. The decision to come back among us loaded with virus has some chance to turn out badly.
 
The agreement to bring Dr. Kent Brantly to the facility was between Emory University Hospital and Shepard's Purse. They are both non-government organizations (NGOs), which means that the arguments for or against the use of military medical facilities (ie, government facilities) are moot.

I still support the decision to do this.
Are you trying to say that the CDC had no involvement in the decision to bring the Americans home? Who do you thing is responsible for the hospital having the isolation unit in the first place? The CDC.
 
Why do I need to post evidence? I asked you where you got your information, so I would think you should be providing the evidence. You're the one making assumptions.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

Hello; I too would like to know if there were many guards surrounding the area and also that no unauthorized people were within a mile of the Emory facility. Knowing such a level of security was used would be a comfort. I hope that was not simple speculation.
 
Hello; I too would like to know if there were many guards surrounding the area and also that no unauthorized people were within a mile of the Emory facility. Knowing such a level of security was used would be a comfort. I hope that was not simple speculation.
The woman who filmed the arrival was visiting a patient in the hospital. What does that tell you?
 
another day, and another day of :ROFL:, for this thread,
heather thanks but they are not listening. i am really disappointed in allot of the comments, on the bright side they both seem to be doing better, great stuff, they have laid there lives on line to help them folks in the worst possible conditions to get a grip on it. seems we sending out 50 educated professionals in several fields to help them get a grip on this out break. :)
 
Has anyone watched the news? There's a patient with Ebola-like symptom just walked in Mount Sinai in New York today. He just recently travelled to west Africa. The patient is kept isolation for now, and according to witness at that hospital, the emergency room was still packed, after the patient was checked in Now go back and bury your head in the sand
 
I did here that, again understand the virus, even if he is has it and showing the first signs, unless you give him a big fat wet kiss while he has bleeding gums, you are not going to get it. this is not influenza, it is not air born. talk about pulling your head out of the sand, read up on the dang thing. other wise just a talking head troll.
 
Dang, get off MFK for 30 minutes and look it up an read about it, do not take my word for it.
 
Why do I need to post evidence? I asked you where you got your information, so I would think you should be providing the evidence. You're the one making assumptions.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

going from a given (the guy is here and no dead folks lining the street )ya might want to start with the assumption that the people who do these things for a living might just be smart enough not to have chanced people getting anywhere near the infected doctor.. do you really think that you could get within 500 yrds of him during transfer?...that's CALLED security..that doesn't always include a bunch of BARNEY FIFE TYPES.. maybe that's what you were looking for?...btw... I , NOW THAT MY SUPPOSITION has been proven right (he's in containment, no dead people) , don't really need to provide "proof, the "proof" is in the outcome....the other side of the arguement .."it's toooooo dangerous "...kinda lost some steam...don'tcha think?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MonsterFishKeepers.com