So how strict are you at keeping a biotope?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

How 'racist' are you when it comes to mixing fish from different countries

  • If they're not from the same river I won't mix them!

    Votes: 2 2.9%
  • Try and keep it within the same continent, similar habitats.

    Votes: 22 32.4%
  • If they've got similar requirements then I'll mix it up.

    Votes: 29 42.6%
  • My tank is one big global melting pot!

    Votes: 15 22.1%

  • Total voters
    68
Ever since I started my amazon biotope I've been really picky on what fish I keep. The only non South American fish I have is a endli.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
I'm fairly open to the idea of mixing fish from different biotopes, as long as they can thrive in my tank setup (water parameters, temp, lighting, substrate, etc) and aren't constantly fighting amongst each other, then why not?

I do however understand the idea of keeping a strict biotope and one day would love to give it a shot.

In the end I really think it comes down to creating an interesting display that you can enjoy. Be it %100 correct to what you'd find in nature, all the way down to the type of rocks and wood used; or a hodgepodge of fish moved out of their grow outs into a display. :)
 
I try not to make unsolicited suggestions for what people stock (unless I see someone with an RTC in a 10G), but to be honest the first thing I thought when I saw your setup was 1.) man, that is a beautiful display! The second thought, was that the tank would look awesome with a school of Clown Loaches cruising along the bottom.

My only concern would be finding CLs large enough to end up off of your Aros lunch menu. I raised a baby aro along with some small CLs and the Aro's growth rate obviously outpaced the CLs and eventually the Aro tried picking them off.

But back to the purpose of the thread...I can understand the desire to maintain a biotope setup, but I stock first and foremost on ultimate fish size, then water parameters, temperament and typical water column swimming level considerations over geographic origin. Variety is the spice of life and that's why my tank is more of a melting pot than a strict biotope. I don't think I will ever have a tank without CLs because they add so much color and it's fun to watch how they interact...sort of like cichlids with their own little group hierarchy, but without the hyper aggressiveness (I should say usually...I had a CL that was the reincarnation of Adolf Hitler).
 
I would keep a purer biotope perhaps if there were utility fishes from each region. There are certain fishes that are good algae control like Siamese Algae Eaters and Bushy-nosed Ancistrus that end up in every tank I have. Also I try to have a small peaceful loach in each tank, such as the YoYo Loach for any snails that may pop up. Having said that I tend to have plants from all over the tropics in every tank, so purity is probably a moot point.
 
Setting up a tank with fish all from the same continent can result with as much variety as throwing random fish from all over the world together. Unless you stick to the same water system that the fish would naturally interact in, it isn't a true bio tope in my opinion.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com