Tragedy, check your heaters

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Open Water Predator

Candiru
MFK Member
Jan 4, 2007
160
0
46
Cincinnati, OH
This post is for my friend, Vitaly.

While away he got the terrible news. His 180g tank had exploded. Now I've gotten bad news about my fishroom while on vacation but never of this magnitude.

"Why would a 180 just burst?" he asked. "I don't even want to go home." Many of us can relate to this feeling. The dread of knowing of mess, and heart-wrenching loss awaits us. We made arrangements to meet up once he got back.

When he got back in town, I met him at house. This was last Friday night. We looked over the remains of his once great 180g setup. Upon inspection, it seems pretty clear what happened.

For one reason or another, his heater caught fire, melted the sump under the tank. The resulting fire caused the tank bottom to fail. The 180 gallons of water then extinguished the fire.

Please see the attached pictures.

The sump is completely melted.

The tank failure does not show the characteristics of a stress fracture, as would be expected if the failure were due to torsion, etc.

What's more, this week my wife called me at work to tell me that she had just heard on NPR that United Pet Group was recalling approximately 1.2 million heaters because of potential fire hazards. A quick Google search reveals that United Pet Group is the umbrella corporation that owns Marineland, Lifeguard, and Tetra; among others. If I remember correctly (Vitaly please chime in), his heater was a 500W Blue Line. While I'm not familiar with this brand, I'm willing to bet it's somehow related to this recall.

Understandably, my friend, Vitaly, is so disheartened and disgusted that he doesn't even want to think about or deal with anything. Who can blame him? "I'll probably just get drunk," he said to me last Friday night. I tried to encourage him to follow up. Contact the manufacturer. This was serious. He could've lost more than his 180 gallon aquarium and its residents. He could've lost everything. He could've come home to a smoldering pile of rubble. The whistle needed to be blown. This was before I knew of the recall. So the word is out, which is good. Vitaly, I still encourage you, once you're up for it, to contact the manufacturer of your heater. There's a good chance they'll make compensation for your loss.

What do you guys think? What says the public opinion?

IMG_0523.JPG

IMG_0524.JPG

IMG_0525.JPG

IMG_0521.JPG

IMG_0519.JPG

IMG_0518.JPG

IMG_0516.JPG

IMG_0514.JPG

IMG_0513.JPG

IMG_0526.JPG
 
Wow I'm really sorry to see this happen. I've heard of heaters exploding and leeching toxins in the water, killing everything. But how does a submerged heater get hot to the point where it is capable of melting a sump and starting a fire?
 
=S my regards... im glad some of his polys made it at least but just wow...
 
shua71;5074399; said:
Wow I'm really sorry to see this happen. I've heard of heaters exploding and leeching toxins in the water, killing everything. But how does a submerged heater get hot to the point where it is capable of melting a sump and starting a fire?


The heater shorts out and the fire starts in the cord causing the outlet to catch fire and whatever else is flamable near it(wall + curtains, stand,sump,etc...).

Wow that's a bum deal!!! I hate for anyone to have to go through something like that. Sorry for the loss!!!

I just exchanged my marineland stealth today. I've had it a year with no issues but what happened here is exactly what I wanted to avoid.

Best of luck,
---Chris
 
pi-eyed;5074427; said:
The heater shorts out and the fire starts in the cord causing the outlet to catch fire and whatever else is flamable near it(wall + curtains, stand,sump,etc...).

Wow that's a bum deal!!! I hate for anyone to have to go through something like that. Sorry for the loss!!!

I just exchanged my marineland stealth today. I've had it a year with no issues but what happened here is exactly what I wanted to avoid.

Best of luck,
---Chris

im taking 3 in monday for this reason... time for more fluvals
 
Those Poly's made it through all that? They pretty much extinguished the sump fire....no major injuries?
 
Polys are possibly one of the hardiest freshwater fish, I won't be surprise if they made it.
They can breathe oxygen directly from the atmosphere and as long as their skin stays moist, they can live without water.

To OP, your friend should ask the company for compensation. This is really no joke. What if the water fail to extinguish the fire and burn his whole house down. I say demand a 180g from the company. That is what they owe you.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com