Which focal Fish for 55G?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Sab_Fan;4282154; said:
a lot of these suggestions - - Red Texas, Jaguar, Green Terror - - would outgrow a 55G eventually . . .

you might want to consider something a bit smaller, like a Blue Acara or an EBJD

EBJD can get just as large as a regular Jack, which will also outgrow a 55 gallon.

BUT, I am sure by the time it outgrows it, they can get a larger tank.
 
Sab_Fan;4282154; said:
a lot of these suggestions - - Red Texas, Jaguar, Green Terror - - would outgrow a 55G eventually . . .

you might want to consider something a bit smaller, like a Blue Acara or an EBJD
I agree, there have been a lot of terrible suggestions in this thread. To the OP, don't get any fish that can get to over 10-12" or you will just end up having to rehome it.



mshill90;4282161; said:
EBJD can get just as large as a regular Jack, which will also outgrow a 55 gallon.

BUT, I am sure by the time it outgrows it, they can get a larger tank.

That's never a good thing to assume, especially without ketting the OP know that you are suggesting fish that will outgrow their tank. Most of the time, even those who claim to have plans for future upgrades never do follow through with it.
 
drgnfrc13;4282195; said:
With a FH, there's a chance that it could outgrow a 55g.


Then why don't you just have him keep a goldfish?

Oh wait... they will also outgrow a 55.

Just keep tetras.

It's a shame because I can find more than 20 posts on here with people keeping JD's etc in 55 gallon tanks.

I keep my JD in a 55 gallon and he's 10". And he's got plenty of room.
 
mshill90;4282205; said:
Then why don't you just have him keep a goldfish?

Oh wait... they will also outgrow a 55.

Just keep tetras.

It's a shame because I can find more than 20 posts on here with people keeping JD's etc in 55 gallon tanks.

I keep my JD in a 55 gallon and he's 10". And he's got plenty of room.
I'm sorry, I don't recall ever saying they would outgrow a 55 gallon... If I remember correctly, you're the one who said a JD could outgrow a 55 gallon, which actually usually isn't the case. Oh and to be honest, I really don't even understand what you meant by the rest of your post...
 
drgnfrc13;4282218; said:
I'm sorry, I don't recall ever saying they would outgrow a 55 gallon... If I remember correctly, you're the one who said a JD could outgrow a 55 gallon, which actually usually isn't the case.


There are people who keep jags, flower horns etc in 55 gallon tanks.

Most people on this forum who are really in it for the fish will upgrade when they need to, so don't assume he won't.


I've never seen a jag outgrow a 55 gallon, nor a flowerhorn. So someone please post pics, and show us.
 
Gulper Catfish
 
why not just an oscar fish
dont really get passed 10-12inchs
one will be fine in a 55 with good filtration
Ps: ive never seen a jack or GT grow big enough to out grow a 55
but a jag yes
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com