I have been one to say no to lj and uj mixing only because of the huge size discrepancy that can occur especially early on. It's a fact larger fish eat smaller ones. It can happen with two really off sizes of ljs or ujs too. I'm not trying to villanize the endlis. It's like with what happens with pits, or dobbies, or rots when in fact smaller dogs account for more bites then larger every year. I've seen huge tanks with crazy size differences too. Once again it's like the dogs more so the owner then the animals that are to blame.
That said I had a bad endli or, really a bad sales person at a lfs when I was young. So that has kind of slanted my opinion a bit.
It looks good, just be cautious and keep them fed well.
Do you feel this way because of experience or does it just "look" not right (the size diff)
What did the bad endli do ?
Sure smaller fish get eaten but your completely exaggerating it in this situation man. 15 in lj and a 9 inch uj sound like a big difference, but it isn't. Im totally on board with cb sens and lj being a no no but other than that I'd like to see actual examples where keeping lj and up together doesn't work. Can predation happen ? Absolutely but it's not as common as it seems.
BTW I had a tiny seen and big 17/18 inch dabola endli together. That sen was the only fish the endli DIDNT attack. Still the size diff was just that wide of a gap to warrant them not being kept together as the sen was a skinny 5 or 6 inches.
I probably have had more aggressive uj than lj.
Sure someone may have had an endli eat it's tankmate but for some unknown reason juvie endli can be known to do this. Doesn't mean all endli or all lj will.
TBH I stopped keeping the two together because I like things symmetrica. I don't like the pearsei/het combo or the jag/vulture combo just like the up/lj combo not because they can't be kept with each other but because it does aesthetically please me.
I get the dog comparison but don't see how it applies. Are you saying the lj's will eat the uj's ? Or just and aggression thing ?
I can tell you from personal experience that any aggression from lj was never directed at a specific tankmate ie uj, but always spread out indiscriminately.
Infact only the ornate (upperjaw) routinely attacked smaller Polys.
I hope no offense is taken by this disagreement I always value your opinion and you absolutely are a great poly keepers it's just I see allot of new members being told uj and lj can't be kept together and it's simply not true.