75G Oscar Tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Thank you all for your input. I have done a bit more research and have come across Severums and I am leaning towards this stocking

2 Green Severums
4 Firemouths
2 Pictus
Potentially 1 Senegal Bichir
 
To be honest with I’d hold off on the bichir might get to big for the tank. Instead get more Pictus they do best in groups of 3 or more but for a 75 I’d say 3-4 would be good
 
What is your water like in terms of ph and hardness? Severums are south American cichlids that would do better in soft to neutral water. Also, the green severum gets quite large (up to 10+ inches with a tall, thick frame). For a 75, a single rotkeil severum would be better as they supposedly max out around 8 in. I think if you really want another cichlid to go with the firemouths, a single blue acara or electric blue acara would be better.
 
What is your water like in terms of ph and hardness? Severums are south American cichlids that would do better in soft to neutral water. Also, the green severum gets quite large (up to 10+ inches with a tall, thick frame). For a 75, a single rotkeil severum would be better as they supposedly max out around 8 in. I think if you really want another cichlid to go with the firemouths, a single blue acara or electric blue acara would be better.
The total hardness is about 75ppm, alkalinity 40ppm and ph at around 6.5. Tbh I’m just looking for a bigger fish with personality that’ll go with the firemouths
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ash02
Totally understandable. I can attest that acaras can have a lot of personality. Also, I believe some dominant male firemouths are capable of getting pretty big (8+ inches). I'm sure one of the more experienced members can confirm.
 
I’ve kept picture catfish and Senegal bichirs in a 75 gallon and I’ve found the picture to be too active for the tank size and senegals are perfect for a 75 in terms of size and activity so you wouldn’t have to worry about them being too active or getting too large.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HybridFinatic
I had a Senegal bichir attempt to eat a pictus cat once, thought both fish were going to die. Bichir eventually coughed up the pictus and lived. But I wouldn't recommend the two together, bichirs tend to eat elongated fish.

On the cichlids; if you have water with a pH of 6.5 that's not really ideal for firemouths or other central americans. There are many ways to raise your pH a bit though, I would recommend a bag of crushed coral in your filter. Won't be a dramatic affect but will help add more mineral content to water and should bring up pH a bit.
The severum would do fine in the lower pH but personally I like to keep CA fish with CA fish and SA with SA, due to the differences in water preference. Though, both fish have been in the hobby for a long time and will be adaptable if you get captive bred specimens (mostly what's available)
If it were my tank I would pick either the severum or the firemouths and build the stock around them. Severum, perhaps blue acara, some large bodied tetras, your pictus cats, for a SA theme. Or, group of 6ish firemouths with some livebearers like swordtails, which they live with in wild and makes a nice display.
Another possibility, which the purist in me finds hard to recommend, would be to keep a severum with your firemouth and add your pictus cats, which seems to be what you want to do. This might actually work fine, but mixing different species of cichlids especially from different continents is a balancing act, and it's going to be up to your fish whether they play nice or fight each other. I'd say it's 50/50. Better odds of working out if you add one more smaller cichlid like a blue acara. If you attempt this, have another tank running on standby incase you need to remove a trouble maker.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com