OK guys, I've read this thread and hear some desperation and frustration. I realize that I have a different mind set and a completely different perspective. For some people, it's all about the receiving. Every year, someone on MFK will start a thread "What did you get for Christmas?"
Frankly, for years the political expediency of getting gifts for people who don't want or need or will use whatever you spend your time and money purchasing has gotten me down on the whole experience. I have felt that I was just throwing money away. It got easier when I started just giving cash when a gift "needed" to be given. When I tell my husband that I don't want anything, I am dead serious. (But not every woman may be serious) Somehow it falls on deaf ears. When I think back over the years, three of his gifts really touched me in a profound manner, probably because so much of his time was invested in each gift. One year he gave me a musical saw. He had to drive 9 hours to purchase the saw. It was a complete surprise. Another time he made a cat tree, welding and assembling it at his parents' house.
Another time he completely refinished my harp bench, turning an ugly used bench into a beautiful piece. This week I went to an equipment auction with him. It was cold and rainy and generally miserable. I kept warm and dry. When he commented on having never seen the coats I was wearing, I told him that he had given them both to me in Christmases past....so it turns out that his gifts that I had no use for really were thoughtful gifts that I eventually used.
So if you are really flummoxed, what do you do? Ask her. Listen very carefully and pay attention to what she says. What she talks about is where her interests lie. You need to perfect the art of reading between the lines. Women communicate indirectly, while men generally communicate directly.
Example: Three men are talking about a fourth individual, saying what a slob he is. Each man will agree while he wipes the ketchup drips from his hamburger off his shirt. Same scenario with three women will result in each woman wondering if the other two are talking about her.
So listen and pay attention. BTW, the spa idea is great--women love to be pampered. The thoughtful gift means the world, but you will have to perfect the art of listening. Good luck my MFK friends!