Thank goodness! Just think of it as a grotto rather than a cave.
Cool story about the eel. The cynic in me, never far from the surface, couldn't help but notice that the documentation for this oddity seems to mainly consist of the testimony of a real estate agent selling the property. Did he/she suss out the potential buyers, and upon learning that they would consider an eel in the well a quaint positive rather than a repulsive negative, perhaps put a few embellishments on the tale? I wonder how many different eels have lived their lives out in that well, to be quietly replaced when they stopped appearing when visited.
Sort of a modern version of the weather-forecasting groundhogs, but with the details of new recruits replacing the old quietly ignored. Hmmm?
I really hope that well wasn't used for drinking water...