festae pictures and transformation

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
fishluvr12;4970956; said:
OP's festae is male

Did you sell it to him, or know who did? If not, how can you be so sure? By the way the last pic I posted was a male. And a mean:angryfire SOB at that, but he does let the female live long enough to spawn with her then he's removed.
 
bomillyiam;4971092; said:
Did you sell it to him, or know who did? If not, how can you be so sure? By the way the last pic I posted was a male. And a mean:angryfire SOB at that, but he does let the female live long enough to spawn with her then he's removed.

I don't know for sure, it just looked male to me in the pic.I bought 2 several yrs back(as females) that looked like it ,but they turned out to be male.
 
surfpalmsncycads;4967148; said:
i was going to go make another guess my sex thread but ill cut the chase somewhat short. ive posted this fish many times and got the same response every single time. is this male or female? answers will come tomorrow afternoon.

looks like a cool set up, do you have any full tank shots?
 
bomillyiam;4969742; said:
Males can get red on face and chin and they also can display dark dorsal but usually when brood protecting. There are also males with no spangling. But these are exceptions, not rules.

Anyone wanna take a stab at this one?
looks male.

On a side note, it's not always easy, or reliable, to sex fish from pictures
 
even i was originaly onboard with the male gues. the fish had tons of spangling throu out the body. it has always had the semi darker upper dorsal but so do some of my males and ive detemined that isnt always a dead give away. i put a divider in my largest festaes tank and put him her in and in a matter of 20 minutes it was clear what she was. tank is 110 gal 5 foot long 24 tall. my male is a solid 13+ inches pure beast. im going to say shes 8 inches or so. thought smaller until i caught her, shes nice even out of the water. sorry for the following pics there from my cell. i have nice shots i took with my cam but for some reason my usb to camera isnt working. gonna try to upload the sd card in another computer. heres a few shots

IMAG0423.jpg

IMAG0424.jpg

IMAG0436.jpg

IMAG0428.jpg

IMAG0430.jpg

IMAG0431.jpg

IMAG0433.jpg

IMAG0434.jpg

IMAG0438.jpg

IMAG0437.jpg

IMAG0435.jpg
 
another observation over the years i noticed too, ive looked at thousands of festae pictures as im sure you all have. there has never been a female ive seen that doesnt have a broken Y bar. thats why i was so sure mine was male too. then i put her in and now the Y bar is blotchy when it was flawless before. looks like her bar will also have a break in it.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com