haggling a fish away from petsmart

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Great post esox,that might even make for a good email as well if it got to someomone in corporate who actually cares about the animals that are sold in their stores.The same goes for the store manager,I doubt that he cares very much about any of the lifestock there.....
 
my take, if someone refuses an offer, it just means the offer isn't too good to refuse

the tank may be a bit narrow but on the bright side, after 2 years, it still looking healthy
my take, if someone refuses an offer, it just means the offer isn't too good to refuse

the tank may be a bit narrow but on the bright side, after 2 years, it still looking healthy

I'm not sure what you're suggesting, but I agree with the second part.
 
Great post esox,that might even make for a good email as well if it got to someomone in corporate who actually cares about the animals that are sold in their stores.The same goes for the store manager,I doubt that he cares very much about any of the lifestock there.....

On the contrary, there must be someone at the store who has an attachment to the fish, hence the corny sign and adamant "not for sale" stance. I have yet to find out who that it is though.
 
I agree with your ideals. The only point I have to make is its retail not a true pet shop. Yes they sell animals but in reality they sell things for animals more so.
Someone posted about the manager not caring because its not commission, true but most retail store managers have a bonus based off of numbers and one of the numbers is sales $ and % above last year. So the manager should be trying to make sales and encouraging their team members to do the same.

While what you say is true, I highly doubt one fish sale is gonna put a dent in that quarterly report. That store probably sells 10k in dog food every day.

I'm merely suggesting they take a couple hundred out of the budget to set up one of the larger tanks they frequently stock. I don't think its unreasonable, but then again I work for a large corporation as well, so I understand just how stingy they can be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twentyleagues
On the contrary, there must be someone at the store who has an attachment to the fish, hence the corny sign and adamant "not for sale" stance. I have yet to find out who that it is though.
If they cared any more than having a store mascot they would have let someone who claimed to have a better home purchase the fish.
 
If they cared any more than having a store mascot they would have let someone who claimed to have a better home purchase the fish.

Well like I said I think it's probably someone who is personally attached to the fish, and possibly has some sway or has been working there for awhile . That person is likely the aquatics departments "expert" at that location and none of the higher ups know any better or don't care enough to change it.

To be clear, I'm agreeing with you in that they should consider the welfare of the fish above its value as an exhibit in their demo tank. But I do think they've had many offers from people who wanted the fish, hence the prominent not for sale signs and whatnot.
 
I mean, anything that can be bought will be bought as long as the offer is high enough.....

That could be a lot of offers but it is just not enough

But the fish cannot be bought! They won't sell. I wish I could impart to you how prominent the "not for sale" sign is on the tank. Ill get a picture of it next time.

Are you implying I should go in there and offer a simply ridiculous amount of money for the fish? I think that's a little unreasonable. I would be willing to go as high as $100 maybe. In my previous negotiations we never got around to talking turkey though. As I said, they were staunchly opposed to even taking offers.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com