id these please?

[teleost]

The below fish is a highfin carpsucker from the same location.

Your fish is neither.

 

[meepster]

so what is it?

 

[kafiltafiisch]

has anyone figured out this conundrum?

 

[Rockbass6]

has anyone figured out this conundrum?

Gizzard Shad

 

[kafiltafiisch]

but gizzards have a spot on their side

 

[Rockbass6]

but gizzards have a spot on their side

I see those fish all the time and everyone calls them gizzard shad. None of them really look like the one teleost posted. not that his isn't, I just think its an off picture. The ones I see look identical to the ones midnight caught. I see those and mooneye everywhere in the marinas right after iceout.

 

[pirahna1950]

Try this: A. (P.) pseudoharengus AKA Alewife.

 

[Rockbass6]

Try this: A. (P.) pseudoharengus AKA Alewife.

Alewife are too small and he caught it in flordia.

 

[meepster]

alewife are too small. The head shape is still different from an alewife.

Should we send these pics to a university or something? I seriously hope that these aren't european bream...

 

[midnight]

alewife are too small. The head shape is still different from an alewife.

Should we send these pics to a university or something? I seriously hope that these aren't european bream...

i will send the pix to someone