Rate this Reef for me

[BrtnBoy449]

i saw it in person and trust me, its at least a 9 or a 10

 

[csx4236]

i would give it a 6

 

[MrGuyPerson]

I'd say a 6. The color is too pink overall. You need to ditch the clams. They don't have enough light. Zoanthids and Ricordia spp. are great for color with low light.

 

[Nic]

for a first time set up its nice but not too appealing to me who has had and seen lots of different corals.... to many too pink... i would put the rock into U shapes on each side.... i cant put a number on it but too many soft corals for me im more sps and prefer the montiporas and acropora corals... but over all she did a nice job and i have faith with a better budget there will be a true show stopper there

 

[KansasFishGuy]

it is a great reef setup no doubt, but for my taste it is looks alittle too unatural with the live rock placement. To symmetic for my taste, but great job on it all.

 

[ewurm]

Wow, it's redone. Props to the intern. Maybe let her off cleaning toilets for a week?

 

[QueenslandeR]

i'd give it an 8

 

[Rakie]

It looks like reef on a budget!

It will get a low grade from reef people, but a 10/10 for the lamen...

Good job!

Yeah... Not very aesthetically pleasing... id give it an extremely generous 3.

 

[niblit]

Looks good.Maybe throw in a trumpet fish and a few Tangs to break up the symetry.Over all 8+

 

[fshfanatic]

I would give it a 6-7. It is still in its infancy. Needs to "grow out" I am sure it will be incredible in 6 months or so,