Ya know what....you're right. The first fish is Carpinte. Sorry for the misquote.
Here's picture of one of my Cyanaguttatus. I always look at the pearling. Color isn't always a good indicator...especially in photos. Color balance and other factors can really skew it one way or another.
After I read your response I looked at it again...then at one of mine...and it was obvious. Like I have said many times, I've been wrong before. Thanks for catching it.
"Texas"
View attachment 712249
View attachment 712250
Carpinte "media luna"
View attachment 712251
See how photos can be deceiving....a very old photo I took before I switched to overhead lighting.
View attachment 712252
View attachment 712253
Juvenile Carpinte "Rio Salto"
View attachment 712254
Adult...same fish
View attachment 712255
View attachment 712256