First group of Discus.. some advice

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
what it comes down to is are you happy. yes your fish are a bit stunted, but I have seen worse. they may not reach dinner plate size or be perfectly shaped, but if your ok with 4-5" fish then don't worry about it. you need to adjust your maintenence. wc's are your fishes best friend. you can't change too much water. the only way to get around this is to buy adults.but even they need more wc's than most other species. before spending anymore money, make sure you are going to commit to the care that these fish need. discus are not for eveyone. there are many beautiful species that are less demanding.

very good reply. i too thought about discus in the past, but like u just said the xtra work/time they need, its not for me i went with angles as a 2nd choice,even tho discus are my fav im just too lazy to keep them ,had about 2 years morning when my angles pasted, now i got sds seems i like the disk shape
 
Google "How to pick healthy Discus" and a few items should pop up. You really don't care how stunted Discus look right? Only care that they swim in your tank? Well, for one, they won't swim for very long in your tank if they're stunted. The toxins I'm talking about are not associated with nitrates or ammonia. Lets say you take a crap and piss in a bucket. Run it through a filtration unit to where it gets rid of Ammonia, nitrite, nitrate. Would you still drink it? I'll answer for you, No. Why? Because there is still impurities left in the water. This is what I meant. Discus stunt very easily. The fact that you failed to do research before purchasing your Discus just shows that you ARE a noob. It doesn't matter if you have 100x turn over rate on your filtration system. If you do not do large water changes, your Discus will become stunted. Good luck, because your Discus will need it.


you must not know how water company get their water. reason for chlorine in our water? its because its recycled water! but i agree on the water change. there really is not excuse for nt doing water change every day if youre keeping discus. i have adults as well as juvies and i change their water the same amount. i suggest investing in an aqueon water changer. best investment you can make. i change 5 tank everyday without breaking a sweat and no im not talking 55's im talking 125+
 
you must not know how water company get their water. reason for chlorine in our water? its because its recycled water! but i agree on the water change. there really is not excuse for nt doing water change every day if youre keeping discus. i have adults as well as juvies and i change their water the same amount. i suggest investing in an aqueon water changer. best investment you can make. i change 5 tank everyday without breaking a sweat and no im not talking 55's im talking 125+
Thanks for your help.. i have given up on the other guy just trying to be an A hole.. I did research on the fish.. a lot of fish write ups contradict each other and are misleading.. So i came here for advice. I have a aqueon water changer.. it's great! I have six tanks.. my 100g is one of the smallest. I keep rays, and rare piranha that are very demanding.. have never had an issue with them. I'm going to add a few more and see how it goes for me. I will up my wc interval.. I'm not doing them everyday.. if that does not work for these fish.. then I won't get anymore.. I have drank the water I'm changing from these guys tanks actually.. cause a write up said it needs to be clean enough to drink.. so I have.. very pristine water.
 
sorry man,but you have to keep in mind that you need to really really study and ask more experienced keepers before you spend money for fancy fish. temp is off and always add a decent amount of fish especially if they are aggressive. from mbunas to discus. more research man.ive been down this road before. good luck
 
sorry man,but you have to keep in mind that you need to really really study and ask more experienced keepers before you spend money for fancy fish. temp is off and always add a decent amount of fish especially if they are aggressive. from mbunas to discus. more research man.ive been down this road before. good luck

Thanks man.. I will add three more at once this weekend. They are cheap to me.. I got mine all for 55-78 bucks. I guess you guys are paying more for yours, so that's why you mention them costing a lot? Probably much better fish though from what I have read
 
Thanks man.. I will add three more at once this weekend. They are cheap to me.. I got mine all for 55-78 bucks. I guess you guys are paying more for yours, so that's why you mention them costing a lot? Probably much better fish though from what I have read

yea man i have mobas and wc demasoni mbunas, and assorted discus. i buy from the same breeders so yeah. but i would love a deal for 55-78$ lol. hook me up. :)
 
Thanks for your help.. i have given up on the other guy just trying to be an A hole.. I did research on the fish.. a lot of fish write ups contradict each other and are misleading.. So i came here for advice. I have a aqueon water changer.. it's great! I have six tanks.. my 100g is one of the smallest. I keep rays, and rare piranha that are very demanding.. have never had an issue with them. I'm going to add a few more and see how it goes for me. I will up my wc interval.. I'm not doing them everyday.. if that does not work for these fish.. then I won't get anymore.. I have drank the water I'm changing from these guys tanks actually.. cause a write up said it needs to be clean enough to drink.. so I have.. very pristine water.


you mention that if these dont go well you wont be getting more. well i hate to burst bubbles but theydidnt started out well. so no matter what you do you wont end up ahead, thats why i suggest starting over on quality stock. between 55-78 buck per fish you could have gotten super quality ones from kenny.most gets discourage from keeping discus by buying bad ones from the star. there are many approach to raising discus but the number one rule is start with a nice quality one. also anything under 4 inch should be put in bare bottom tank for easy cleaning. if you hate the look of bare bottom then i suggest starting with discus over 4 inches.
 
It has started out just fine for me.. I have colorful active fish that i love lol.. they are not the perfect discus like you guys keep.. but it doesn't matter to me.. lol I'm not a discus fanatic, I am on rays and piranha and a perfect specimen would matter to me with them. these fish it does not matter as much to me, they are just fish to fill a tank and watch swim. Kinda like getting a perfect goldfish lol. to most it does not matter they just want a fish ha ha..
 
It has started out just fine for me.. I have colorful active fish that i love lol.. they are not the perfect discus like you guys keep.. but it doesn't matter to me.. lol I'm not a discus fanatic, I am on rays and piranha and a perfect specimen would matter to me with them. these fish it does not matter as much to me, they are just fish to fill a tank and watch swim. Kinda like getting a perfect goldfish lol. to most it does not matter they just want a fish ha ha..

no discus is perfect unless its a show discus what im getting at is you will soon have sick fish, defrm fish and fish that when you look at you wonder why other like it. stunted isnt just that they wont grow it affects their health.
 
Oh I see what your saying! I'm trying to decide if I should even get more then?? If all my LFS has stunted ones... IDK about that then
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com