Hello; OK, as is the norm in so many threads we get to a place where there are differences of opinion. This is the way it nearly always works out so let me call it normal. We may be at the point in the thread where we go around and around the same points until the thread dies out.
So before this happens here is an idea. Someone makes up a short code of some sort for the various situations. For example only and not indicated to be the format for the code other than it be short.
Never kept the fish = NKF
I have actual experience = HE (maybe HE 8 for eight years experience)
I have read about it = HR
I have read about it from a trusted source = HRT
my best guess based on similar experience = BGE
My best guess based on nothing = BGDA
I am a troll and only care about stirring things up = CARP
The codes could be based on some other format such as bold print for actual experience, italics for opinion, underlined for from a trusted source.
The format could be something else entirely. I nominate Hendre to come up with samples of such a code seeing as how he is apparently the inspiration for this thread. Maybe he can con one of his teachers into making it an assignment and get credit that way.