Gender My Jack Dempsey

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I’d put my money on the krib tbh. My gourami have only been aggressive with other gourami.
Can you send pics of the current krib?
Me too…. Now … I put the gourami with the JD everything is fine so far ….. I am watching today after tonight I won’t have any worries!!
 
+1

Once had a female Kribensis kill 2 males. One male was killed after he fertilized the eggs.
Yea that’s what I am agreeing with…. Now at least…. So I went ahead and added the gourami with my JD…. There’s plenty of room in my 55 gallon and today I am observing it closely and then as long as my jack Dempsey makes it for tonight I will be OK
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
If the gourami tried to pick a fight I’d bet the jd would win, cichlids are much tougher.
For now they should be fine, jd probably won’t get to bad with it till about 3-4 inches.
 
Yea that’s what I am agreeing with…. Now at least…. So I went ahead and added the gourami with my JD…. There’s plenty of room in my 55 gallon and today I am observing it closely and then as long as my jack Dempsey makes it for tonight I will be OK
Makes it through tonight I feel it will be fine
If the gourami tried to pick a fight I’d bet the jd would win, cichlids are much tougher.
For now they should be fine, jd probably won’t get to bad with it till about 3-4 inches.
Well you couldn’t be more correct that JD runs the gourami LOL ? it’s so small but I went ahead and put them together and the JD seems happy having someone to boss around!!!! LOL ? I am absolutely so much happier than I was being thrown into the care of a JD at 6” cause this is my first baby 2nd JD…… also I was told F JD fish can cause more trouble what would someone mean by that…. Is caring for a female any different from caring for a male of the same species?? Idk ?‍♀️ but I’m not finding anything on it!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
Males will be more outwardly aggressive, but when a female lays eggs - she will go crazy defending the nest. Cichlid aggression is at its worst when you have a male and female pair that is breeding.
When dealing with a solo fish + dithers it really doesn’t make a difference.
 
Males will be more outwardly aggressive, but when a female lays eggs - she will go crazy defending the nest. Cichlid aggression is at its worst when you have a male and female pair that is breeding.
When dealing with a solo fish + dithers it really doesn’t make a difference.
This is wonderful news and that’s exactly what I am doing and considering adding a 2nd cichlid when this one is 3” and I have a male EBA but they are so gentle I don’t think I could combine them…….. but if I were to add in a 2nd one or grow one out in my 55 for my 75 what type cichlid would I need???
Also today I got a really close look almost 2” round fins with 4 blue dots under each eye I’m honestly already thinking I may have a female at least she came from a breeder that I trust !!! After last time…. Idk ?‍♀️ what was going on there!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
A lot of the color traits and finnage take a bit to come in - here’s my male at about 2-3 inches:
89E92A45-AD49-45A7-A3C4-34762A757D0A.jpeg
I already thought he might be a male, but it takes longer for that to really show.
If you are going to do another cichlid, I would either get a few more jd now and wait till a pair forms, or go with a convict or rainbow cichlid. They are tough and can hold their own in a fight, or stay out of one completely. Convict is meaner and would probably be safer, but rainbows can be quite mean as well. Both get about 4 inches or so.
My jd is with a blood parrot, convict, banded leporinus, and a krib (which nobody ate early on and now it’s big).
 
A lot of the color traits and finnage take a bit to come in - here’s my male at about 2-3 inches:
View attachment 1491848
I already thought he might be a male, but it takes longer for that to really show.
If you are going to do another cichlid, I would either get a few more jd now and wait till a pair forms, or go with a convict or rainbow cichlid. They are tough and can hold their own in a fight, or stay out of one completely. Convict is meaner and would probably be safer, but rainbows can be quite mean as well. Both get about 4 inches or so.
My jd is with a blood parrot, convict, banded leporinus, and a krib (which nobody ate early on and now it’s big).
Ok I see well I was thinking about jewel cichlids no male all female is that a bad idea??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
Ok I see well I was thinking about jewel cichlids no male all female is that a bad idea??
Jewel are a toss up - some can be mild, others can be pure evil. A solo is far less aggressive than a pair. Nothing a Jack can’t handle but I’d have a backup plan in case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fishlover420
Jewel are a toss up - some can be mild, others can be pure evil. A solo is far less aggressive than a pair. Nothing a Jack can’t handle but I’d have a backup plan in case.
What if I did 1 jewel and 1 butterfly cichlid but wait until my JD can hold good ground just in case ??? I’m really looking for a cichlid that is not a convict those rainbows are expensive and my pet store won’t sell less than 6 at a time….. I have a krib in a 10 gallon started trying to kill of my community crazy little lady LOL ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
MonsterFishKeepers.com